Lottery and rush tickets come in ones. You enter for one seat because entering for two means buying two if you win, you get the email at 11 in the morning, and by six o'clock you are standing on Eighth Avenue by yourself with ninety minutes to kill and nobody to kill it with. Every pre-theater dinner guide in this city, including a few of mine, is written for two people with a reservation. This one is not.
Eating alone near the theaters is a solved problem, and the solution is a counter. A counter seats one person immediately, charges one person's prices, and nobody files you under "table for one" and parks you by the kitchen door. With the standard Broadway curtain at 7 PM, you want to be sitting by 5:45 and walking by 6:35. A counter is the only kind of room that reliably does that on a Wednesday.
Five places, all of them open as of this week, all of them within a reasonable walk of a Broadway house.
Los Tacos No. 1 — 229 W 43rd St, between Seventh and Eighth
A standing counter inside the arcade, no tables, so there is no wait for a table and no host to explain yourself to. Tacos run about $6 each; three and a drink puts you under $25 and the adobada is the one to get. You order, you eat standing up, you are gone in twenty minutes. Three minutes on foot to the Shubert at 225 W 44th, where Galileo is playing, and about the same to the Hayes. This is the move when the lottery email came in at 4 PM and you have not thought about dinner at all.
Westway Diner — 614 Ninth Ave, at 44th
A real counter with real stools and a menu the length of a phone book. $18 to $26 for a full plate, coffee refilled without asking, and the pacing of a place that has fed people on a clock since before any of us were buying rush tickets. Eight to ten minutes east to the 45th Street houses. It is also the correct answer for a matinee, which I argued at length in the pre-matinee brunch list.
Pure Thai Cookhouse — 766 Ninth Ave, at 51st
Small, loud, stairs, and counter seats that exist specifically for people who came alone. The dry noodles with crab and pork are why anyone stands outside in October waiting for a stool. $18 to $24. Eight minutes to the Gershwin at 222 W 51st for Wicked, a couple more to the Neil Simon for MJ. Go at 5:30 and you will sit; go at 6:15 and you will not.
Joe Allen — 326 W 46th, on Restaurant Row
The bar is the entire reason to put a theater institution on a solo list. Sit at it and you are a regular; ask the host for a table and you are a problem on the busiest hour of their night. $25 to $40 for a plate and a drink. Five minutes to most of the 45th and 46th Street houses. The famous wall of flop posters is a better dinner companion than most actual dinner companions. If you want the rest of that block weighed up honestly, the Restaurant Row piece does it.
Bar Centrale — 324 W 46th, up the stairs between Joe Allen and Orso
Unmarked door, narrow room, no tables to speak of, and the single best place in the Theater District to sit alone with a drink and eavesdrop on people who were on a stage an hour ago. Open Tuesday to Saturday from 5 PM to 11:30, closed Sunday and Monday, and the house strongly recommends calling ahead — they take bookings no more than a week out. Those hours and that policy make it a better post-show room than a pre-show one. Put it on the back half of the night.
And one for after
A 7 PM curtain puts you back on the sidewalk around 9:45, which is when most of the Theater District's kitchens start closing their menus. Schmackary's at 362 W 45th runs 9 AM to 11 PM Sunday through Thursday and to midnight Friday and Saturday, sitting in the middle of the 45th Street houses. It is a cookie shop, which is not dinner, but it is open and it is forty feet from where you are standing. For something with a plate, the after-curtain list has six rooms still cooking at that hour.
Check your list before you walk
Hell's Kitchen lost a lot of counter seating this year, and I would rather tell you now than have you walk twelve blocks for nothing. Totto Ramen is gone from both 51st and 52nd Street. Casellula, the wine and cheese room at 401 W 52nd that was on every solo list in the city for fifteen years, is closed. Ippudo Westside at 321 W 51st is dark. If your mental map of cheap counters up there was built before this year, it is out of date.
The practical version
Won a seat for tonight and have not eaten: Los Tacos. Cold night, want to sit: Westway. Want the meal to be the good part: Pure Thai. Want to feel like you belong to the neighborhood: Joe Allen's bar. Coming out at 9:45 wanting one more hour of the evening: Bar Centrale, Tuesday through Saturday.
If budget is the whole question rather than table size, the cheap pre-theater cornerstone is the place to start, and the block-by-block guide sorts the whole district by which house you are sitting in. If you do not have the ticket yet, the lottery hub is where the single seats come from in the first place.



