Thanksgiving is nine days out, which in New York means the turkey has not been bought yet but the ticket sales have already started. ATG Tickets, the company that runs the box office for a handful of Broadway houses, has a Black Friday and Cyber Monday sale live right now. Punch in the code ATGHOLIDAY at checkout and you save on five shows.
Five. Not the whole street. Here is the list, with ATG's own numbers off its sale page:
- The Book of Mormon at the Eugene O'Neill: up to 40% off
- Hadestown at the Walter Kerr: up to 35% off
- Now You See Me Live at the Al Hirschfeld: up to 30% off
- Harry Potter and the Cursed Child at the Lyric: up to 25% off
- Paranormal Activity at the August Wilson: up to 20% off
If that roster looks familiar, it should. ATG ran a Broadway Fall Sale in September with code FALLSALE on four of these same shows. The holiday version is a little sweeter on paper: Hadestown went from up to 20% to up to 35%, Book of Mormon from 30% to 40%, Cursed Child from 20% to 25%, and Paranormal Activity stayed put at 20%. Now You See Me Live is the new kid.
The catch is in the words "up to"
The sale page does not print a single dollar figure. No "from $59," no seat map, nothing. A percentage off a price you have not seen is a coupon for a mystery box. Twenty percent off a premium orchestra seat and twenty percent off the back row of the balcony are two very different evenings, and you will not know which one you are getting until you are a few clicks deep with a seat map open.
The fine print also says the discount applies to select performances only, not to every price level, not at the box office, not on tickets you already bought, and not stacked with other offers. ATG adds that offer dates may vary by event, so treat this as a now-or-never thing rather than something to sleep on until Cyber Monday.
Every one of these shows already has a cheaper door
Here is why we did the math instead of just reprinting the announcement. All five shows run a lottery or rush at a fixed, published price. So the useful question is not "how much do I save?" It is "how cheap does the seat have to start for the sale to beat the lottery?" Here is the break-even, worked out from ATG's top discount against the cheapest door each show runs:
| Show | Cheapest door | ATG max off | Sale only wins if the seat starts under |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Book of Mormon | $15 monthly lottery, or $49 Lucky Seat | 40% | $25 (vs. $15) / $82 (vs. $49) |
| Hadestown | $39 standing room, or $49 Lucky Seat | 35% | $60 (vs. $39) / $75 (vs. $49) |
| Now You See Me Live | $42 lottery and rush | 30% | $60 |
| Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | $40 Friday Forty | 25% | $53 |
| Paranormal Activity | $40 lottery and rush | 20% | $50 |
Read that bottom row twice. For the sale to beat Paranormal Activity's $40 door, you need a seat that lists for under fifty bucks before the discount, and then you need ATG to apply the full 20% to it. That is a narrow alley.
How to actually get in cheap at each one
The Book of Mormon. Two lotteries, and one of them is ridiculous. The show's own $15 lottery runs monthly: entries close at 11:59 PM ET on the 14th, winners are drawn by 3 PM ET on the 15th and get a link to buy up to two tickets for select dates the following month. December's draw has already happened, so the next shot is for January. Lucky Seat also runs a $49 draw per performance, and TodayTix has a $49 day-of rush.
Hadestown. A $49 Lucky Seat lottery, limit two, with a warning that some lottery seats have an obstructed view. If the performance sells out, the Walter Kerr box office sells $39 standing room on the day, two per person.
Now You See Me Live. Three doors at $42 all-in: a Lucky Seat lottery drawn every morning at 11 AM ET, a TodayTix rush that drops at 9 AM ET on the day, and a general rush at the Al Hirschfeld box office. Our listing shows the run ending January 3, so if a magic show is on your holiday list, do not dawdle.
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. The Friday Forty: $40 tickets through the TodayTix app for the following week's performances. Enter any time from Monday at 12:01 AM to Friday at 1 PM ET. Winners hear that Friday afternoon and pick up at the Lyric box office on the day.
Paranormal Activity. Two ways in at $40: a Lucky Seat lottery and a TodayTix digital rush on the day of the show.
Every lottery and rush on this page lives on our Broadway lottery hub, along with the entry windows for the rest of the street.
When the sale is the right call
Lotteries are cheaper. They are also a lottery. The sale wins on three things the lottery cannot give you.
Certainty. If the in-laws land on the 27th and you need four seats together on a specific night, no lottery on earth is going to sort that out. Most of these doors cap you at two tickets.
Choice of seat. Lottery and rush seats are wherever the show puts you, and sometimes that is partial view. With the sale you pick off the map.
A gift. You cannot wrap a lottery entry. Well, you can, but the recipient will have questions.
If none of those apply, enter the lotteries first and keep ATGHOLIDAY in your back pocket for the night you strike out. For everything else happening between now and New Year's, our holiday survival guide has you covered.



