Blue Man Group Broke Broadway's Two-Ticket Lottery Rule

A row of four empty crimson theatre seats under a single warm spotlight

In this guide

  • The lottery, as the production states it
  • And the window does the same thing for $40
  • Why four tickets matters more than the $35
  • The trade you make for it
  • What I would actually do
  • While you are here

For three years I have given the same answer to the same question. Four of us want to see one show — how do we all win the lottery? You don't. Every digital lottery on this board sells the winner two tickets. Nineteen of them say so in writing, and I wrote a whole post about working around it.

That answer now has an exception, and it arrived on November 10. Blue Man Group – A New Holiday Surprise posted its ticket policies two days before its first performance at the Lunt-Fontanne, and the lottery sells up to four tickets on one entry at $35. The in-person rush does it too: $40, four per person. That is the first door on Broadway I know of that will seat a family of four in a single transaction.

The lottery, as the production states it

Born in the City
Today’s Broadway Lotteries
Live entry times, prices and real odds — updated every day.
See Today’s Lotteries →

It runs on Broadway Direct, which is the Nederlander platform, and the Lunt-Fontanne is a Nederlander house — so the plumbing is the same as every other Broadway Direct show. The numbers are not.

  • $35 a ticket, a limited number per performance.
  • Entry starts 48 hours before the performance and closes 24 hours before. That is unusually early for this platform.
  • Winners are notified within minutes and have 60 minutes to claim and pay.
  • One entry per person per day, up to four tickets per entry.
  • Seats depend on availability and may be partial view.

And the window does the same thing for $40

There is an in-person rush at the Lunt-Fontanne box office — no app, no code, no link. It starts when the box office opens on the day of the performance, with one wrinkle: for 11 AM performances you can buy the day before. The limit is four tickets per person, same as the lottery, and those seats may be partial view too. If you have ever stood in a Broadway rush line you know the drill, and you know how short that line usually is.

Why four tickets matters more than the $35

Do the arithmetic for a group and the exception does real work. Four seats through the lottery is $140. Four through the window is $160. Compare that to the thing most families actually do, which is pay list for four tickets to a holiday show in December, and the gap is not a discount, it is a different evening.

But the part I care about is structural. The two-ticket cap exists so that a handful of winners cannot empty a small pool — that is the whole logic I laid out in the group post. A show that hands one winner four seats is making a different bet: that a family telling other families is worth more than four separate strangers telling four separate circles. For a show built for kids and parents, that bet is obvious in hindsight. It is still the first time I have seen it on this board.

The trade you make for it

Two things get worse in exchange, and neither is in the headline.

The 24-hour cutoff. Most cheap Broadway doors reward flexibility on the day — you wake up, you enter, you find out, you go. This one makes you commit a day early. If the plan is "let's see how everyone feels tomorrow," you have already missed the entry.

The 60-minute claim clock. Sixty minutes is the tight end of the range, and it is the mechanic that quietly sends more cheap seats back in the drawer than bad luck does. I counted the claim windows across the whole board in the claim-clock post, and Broadway Direct's hour is the one people lose. Win notification goes to email. If you enter and then put your phone in a drawer for an afternoon, you did not enter.

What I would actually do

Pick the performance first, then work backwards. Enter 48 hours out, as a group — every adult in the party enters separately for the same performance, because one of you winning four seats is better than two of you winning two pairs in different parts of the house. If nobody wins, walk to 205 West 46th and get in the rush line when the box office opens. Four at $40 with nothing left to chance is a fine outcome, and the line at a brand-new engagement is usually shorter than the line at a show everybody has heard of.

One honest caveat: this is a strictly limited engagement that ends January 3, so the pool is finite and the weeks between Christmas and New Year's are the hardest ones in the year to win anything. If you want the four-ticket math to work for you, the easy weeks are the ones before the tree goes up.

While you are here

Three more from this week. A show opened on West 44th and its cheapest seat turns out to be at the window too. If anyone in your group eats gluten free, four Theater District rooms actually handle it. And if the show you want is already sold out, the door you have probably never used is the cancellation line.

Everything else — every running lottery, every rush, every price — sits on the lottery hub, and the long version of how to work all of it is in How to Win Every Broadway Lottery.

Picture of Bradford Buonasera

Bradford Buonasera

Born, Raised and Still Here. I’m what you’d call a true townie. I was born and raised in Midtown Manhattan, in the very same building where my mother was born and my grandmother lived. That’s three generations of concrete jungle DNA. I love this city, but I know the truth: if you don’t know the ins and outs, Manhattan will empty your wallet before the first intermission. I’m here to change that. I’m sharing decades of local secrets so you can experience the best of New York without the "tourist tax." From front-row Broadway seats to the best hidden gems, consider this your guide to doing NYC like a New Yorker. With that said I love enjoying and sharing all the remarkable things that Manhattan has to offer. Unless you know the ins and outs of NYC it can be expensive. Therefore, I am here to offer all that I have learned over the past few decades on how to do New York City like a New Yorker.