A couple of weeks ago we priced the three literal A Christmas Carols running in this city — the one in a Federal row house on East 4th, the big one at PAC NYC with Andy Karl as Scrooge, and the musical on MacDougal. That post answered a question a lot of people have in November.
This is for everybody else. The ones who have seen Scrooge, who are bringing a friend who would rather be at a bar, who want December in a room of a hundred people instead of a thousand. Nine shows, none of which is A Christmas Carol — except two, which have Carol in the title and are absolutely not it. That is the fun part.
Every date and running time below comes off our own catalogue or the venue's own page. Where a price is posted I have given it. Where one is not, I say so instead of guessing, because three of these nine do not publish a number anywhere a reader can find it, and pretending otherwise is how roundups get people angry.
The Carols that are not the Carol
A Kidman Carol — New World Stages, 340 West 50th. First performance November 16, opening November 30, done December 30. One hour twenty, no intermission. $48 to $214 through Telecharge, which is a real published range and the widest on this list. Marla Mindelle is in it, which if you saw Titanique tells you precisely what register we are in, alongside Josh Sharp, Ashby Florence, Richard Perez and Phillip Taratula. Kevin Zak wrote it, Skylar Fox directs. TDF currently lists no discount seats for it, so that range is the range.
Drunk Christmas Carol — The Ruby Theatre, 35 West 39th, November 12 through January 3, ninety minutes. TodayTix has it from $47. The premise is the title. The one thing worth knowing is that it runs nearly two months, which on this list is a marathon — most of these rooms are in and out inside three weeks.
Tim and Scrooge — 59E59, Theater B, December 16 to 27, ninety minutes, no intermission. This is the most transparently priced thing in this post and I wish more houses did it: $54 including a $4 fee, $40 for 59E59 members, and a $27 "First Look" tier on the first performance, which is already gone. Evenings at 7:15, matinees at 2:15. Twelve performances total — that is the whole run.
The parodies, which are the real December fringe
SoHo Playhouse at 15 Vandam has quietly become the holiday-parody house, and it is running three different things in its main stage slot.
KEVIN!!!!! — December 5 through January 3, sixty minutes, recommended for ages 5 and up. You know what this is. A sixty-minute run time and a five-and-up rating makes it the one entry on this list that genuinely works for a family who cannot sit through two and a half hours. No price on the show page; the box office answers from mid-afternoon until curtain, Wednesday through Sunday.
The (Very Gay) Christmas Prince — December 16 through January 3, seventy-five minutes, 16 and up, performances at 5 PM and 9 PM. A struggling New York baker gets pulled into a royal romance in a fictional country called Swedonia, which is the single most accurate parody of the entire Hallmark industrial complex I have read in a logline. The two showtimes are the useful detail: a 5 PM is a show you can do before dinner, and a 9 PM is one you can do after.
Fly, You Fools! — December 19 to January 2, sixty minutes, same room. Not a holiday show at all; it is a Lord of the Rings send-up, and I am including it because it is the answer for the person in your life who has had enough of December by the 19th. Same house, same length, zero tinsel.
The one that is not for the children
Nutcracker Rouge — Théâtre XIV, 383 Troutman Street, deep in Bushwick. Company XIV's baroque-burlesque Nutcracker returns November 12 for what the company calls twelve weeks only; our board carries it through the end of January. Somewhere between ninety minutes and two hours with an intermission.
This is the most New York item on the list and the furthest from a Broadway house — an L train ride, a graffitied block, and then a room that looks like a Venetian fever dream. No price on the company's own page, which for a show with tiered seating and table service is frankly information they should post. Expect it to cost more than anything else here except the top of the Kidman range.
The family one, and the Broadway one
Nutty Natty's Magic Puppet Show — the Jerry Orbach Theater at the Theater Center, 210 West 50th, third floor. New York premiere from November 14, and the schedule is the whole pitch: Saturdays at 11 AM straight through January 9. Magic, puppets, comedy, audience participation. No price announced beyond "on sale now". An 11 AM Saturday with small children, in Midtown, that lets you do something else in the afternoon is a genuinely useful object and there is almost nothing else like it.
Blue Man Group — A New Holiday Surprise — Lunt-Fontanne, 205 West 46th, November 12 through January 3. The only entry here in a Broadway house, and the only one where the price question is genuinely murky: the company's own site does not post New York holiday-run pricing, and the single discount on it is a newsletter sign-up offering 20% off marked "select cities", with New York not named. Treat that as unconfirmed until you see it apply in your cart.
What none of these has, and why that is normal
Corrected 9 November 2026 — see the correction note at the foot of this post. Eight of the nine post no lottery and no general rush; A Kidman Carol now posts both.
Eight of the nine post no lottery and no general rush. That is not neglect — it is arithmetic. A fixed-capacity room playing a six-week holiday run does not need to give seats away, and most of these houses have nowhere to put a standing-room cohort anyway. If you want a draw to enter, the shows that run them are on the lottery hub, and the how-to-win guide explains which ones are worth the daily habit.
Two practical notes for this stretch of the calendar. First, run times here are short — six of the nine are ninety minutes or less — which makes a dinner-and-a-show evening much easier to schedule than it is with a musical. Second, if you are bringing people in from out of town, book the table before the tickets: a party of six cannot walk in anywhere near Broadway at half past five.
And if you are a student, start here instead: there are three $10 tickets on Broadway, and the newest one is sold at a window on 47th Street with no app involved. Last month's October equivalent of this post is still a good map of how the small rooms price themselves.
Correction, 9 November 2026
When this went up, it said that not one of the nine posts a lottery or a general rush. That was true of all nine when the research was done and it is no longer true of one of them. A Kidman Carol announced two cheap doors on 5 November, the same day this post published: a $30 digital lottery including fees through rush.telecharge.com covering every preview performance from 16 to 29 November, and a $39 digital rush including fees for all performances, released at 11 AM on the day. The lottery is not a daily draw — entries closed 9 November at 11:59 PM, with three drawings only and 24 hours for a winner to pay. Our catalogue now carries both. The argument above needs narrowing rather than scrapping: a fixed-capacity holiday room usually posts nothing, unless it wants help filling previews. Full detail in the five new cheap doors post.



