Three airports serve New York and all three can put you in a Broadway seat without a car. They do it in three completely different ways, the cheapest route is not the obvious one at any of them, and the mistake that strands people is always the same: treating the trip as one ride instead of two.
Every one of these is a two-leg trip. An airport train or bus to a transfer point, then a subway or commuter train into Midtown. Get the first leg right and the second is trivial.
The short version
- JFK — AirTrain to Jamaica or Howard Beach, then subway or commuter rail. Allow two hours from wheels-down to your seat.
- LaGuardia — the free Q70 bus to the 7 train. Allow ninety minutes. This is the cheapest and simplest of the three by a distance.
- Newark — AirTrain to the airport rail station, then a train to Penn Station. Allow two hours.
Add half an hour to any of them if you are collecting a checked bag, and another half hour if the thought of missing a curtain makes you anxious. No usher in this city will seat you mid-scene.
From JFK
You start on the AirTrain, the automated loop that runs between the terminals and two transfer stations. Riding it inside the airport costs nothing — terminal to terminal is free, and the fare is only charged when you enter or leave the system at one of the two outside stations. A single ride out is a little under ten dollars, paid by tapping a contactless card or phone at the gate. The airport posts the exact figure, and it has moved more than once.
Then you pick a transfer point, and the two are not equivalent.
Jamaica is the better choice for a Theater District trip. From there you have two options: the subway, boarding at Sutphin Boulevard–Archer Avenue–JFK Airport, or the Long Island Rail Road, which runs into Penn Station and Grand Central Madison. The airport's own guidance puts either Manhattan terminal about twenty minutes from the AirTrain by rail, and the commuter train is the more comfortable ride by a wide margin — real seats, luggage room, no stairs with a suitcase.
The in-city commuter fare is a few dollars more than a subway tap and there are two price tiers depending on how busy the trains are. Both the railroad and the airport publish the figure; it is worth the premium if you have a bag.
Howard Beach puts you on the A train, and this is where the one real trap on this page lives. The A splits in Queens, and only trains signed for Far Rockaway or Rockaway Park stop at Howard Beach. A train signed for Lefferts Boulevard does not. The transit agency says so plainly in its own airport guidance, which tells you how often people get it wrong. Read the destination on the front of the train, not the letter on the side. It is a long ride back from the wrong branch.
Howard Beach is cheaper, because a subway tap is the least expensive leg in the city. It is also slower and involves the most stairs, and the A train takes a scenic tour of two boroughs before it reaches Midtown.
From LaGuardia
This is the easy one and almost nobody books it. The Q70 — the airport's limited-stop bus — is free for all riders, runs around the clock, arrives about every ten minutes through the day, and goes non-stop between the terminals and the subway. The ride takes roughly ten minutes.
It drops you at 74th Street–Broadway / Jackson Heights–Roosevelt Avenue, which is one of the better transfer stations in the system. From there the 7 train runs straight into Times Square–42nd Street, putting you a block or two from most of the houses. The E, F, M and R are in the same station if your hotel is somewhere else.
The Q70 also stops at Woodside, where every branch of the Long Island Rail Road calls — the move if you would rather pay for a seat and a quiet twenty minutes into Penn Station.
Total cost of the whole trip: one subway tap, around three dollars. Nothing else in this guide comes close.
From Newark
Newark's monorail carries you from the terminals to the airport's own rail station, a leg the transit agency puts at fifteen to twenty minutes. Note before you plan anything tight: that leg is sometimes run as a shuttle bus instead of the train, so read the airport's page before you count the minutes.
From the rail station you have three ways in, in descending order of price:
- Commuter train straight to New York Penn Station. Around an hour by the railroad's own estimate, and the ticket to or from the airport includes the monorail fare, which is the detail people miss when they compare prices. The most expensive option and the most comfortable.
- Commuter train to Newark Penn Station, then the PATH to World Trade Center. Several dollars cheaper and it lands you downtown rather than in Midtown, so add a subway ride if a Broadway house is the destination.
- The #62 bus to Newark Penn Station, then the PATH. Roughly a quarter of the full train fare and the cheapest route from any airport to Manhattan except LaGuardia's free bus. Slower, with a transfer, and perfectly fine with one bag.
One scheduling fact worth storing: the commuter trains stop running overnight, while the PATH and the #62 bus do not. If your flight lands very late or you are heading out before dawn, the bus-and-PATH combination is the route that still exists.
Getting from the train to the curtain
All three routes funnel you into one of three Midtown arrival points, and from each one the last leg is short.
- Penn Station, 34th and Seventh — about a twelve-minute walk up to the 44th Street houses, or one stop on the 1, 2 or 3.
- Times Square–42nd Street — you have arrived. Most Broadway theaters are within four blocks.
- Grand Central — take the S shuttle across to Times Square. Three minutes, one stop, and it is the single most useful train in the system for theatergoers.
The suitcase problem
Here is the part that ruins otherwise good plans. Broadway houses are small, old buildings and most of them have no bag storage and no coat check. Anything bigger than a daypack is a conversation at the door, and the answer is frequently no. If you are coming straight from an airport to a performance, deal with the bag before you deal with the theater — our guide to luggage storage near Broadway covers where to park it within walking distance.
Three habits that make all of this easier
- Tap, do not queue. Every leg above except the commuter railroads takes a contactless card or phone at the gate. You never need to buy a paper ticket for the subway or the AirTrain.
- Check the fare on the operator's own page. Every number in this guide drifts. The airports and the transit agencies each publish the figure and they are the only sources worth trusting on it.
- Read the front of the train. It is true at Howard Beach and it is true across the system. The letter tells you the line, the sign tells you where it actually goes.
Once you are in the neighborhood, the rest of it: which subway lines land where in the Theater District, rooms that serve through the afternoon if you have a gap to fill, and how each ticket lottery platform works if you are hoping to decide what to see after you land. Every running door is on the lottery hub.



